Site Sponsor

Not Sure Where To Begin?

The intro posts are always a good start, followed logically by
my thoughts on Music & Being, which guide my writing.
You could also try my current favorite show on the blog,
plus there's good reading under the trading community label.
Or, take a walk on a
Listening Trail.

Saturday, January 31, 2009

1983 October 11 - Madison Square Garden

Grateful Dead 03/29/83
Tuesday, October 11, 1983
Madison Square Garden – New York, NY
Audience Recording

Here’s one for the record books – the second return of Saint Stephen. I actually like this show for a number of reasons, the least among them being the Saint Stephen itself.

After the song’s first return on 06/09/76, it remained in the rotation throughout 1977, then showed up bookending 1978 (twice in January and twice at the end of December), and once in early January 1979. Gone for over four years thereafter, its second return on 10/11/83 was something of a shot heard ‘round the world. After a 352 show drought, cries for Saint Stephen from the audience had become something of a badge worn by Deadheads. By this point, it was just something that people screamed for, not necessarily believing the tune stood any chance of being played. In fact, you can hear a good handful of these requests coming from the crowd on the evening of its return on October 11th, 1983 too. There’s little doubt that the requesters were any less surprised than the rest of the crowd when it showed up out of Space in the second set.

The song’s return was a huge event. And in my trading circle years ago, what had to be heard from this show was the explosion of recognition and joy on the part of the crowd as the song’s familiar opening lines ring out. Madison Square Garden was electrified, to say the least. This tape got shared a lot because everyone wanted to get a little taste of that moment, and it comes through very nicely indeed. Whether the evening’s rendition of the song managed to even marginally live up to the event of its return is debatable. Regardless, there’s even more happening on this night which is unique, and well worth exploring.

Jerry Garcia 03/29/83The entire show is blessed by having been preserved a few times over by stellar audience recordings. It’s a fun exercise to taste test each of the recordings yourself to see which pleases your ear more. I’m partial to Steve Silberman’s tape – the one that was in circulation when I got my cassettes, and one of the earliest to get transferred into digital circulation. It feels to me that it possesses the most clarity of vocals and musical balance of all masters, and while others might display a bit more low end, I’ve picked Silberman’s as the one to feature here.

Wang Dang Doodle opens. It is about as loose and twisted as any version I’ve heard. Garcia’s backing vocals are extremely wacky, as if he’s hit the stage a few hours into a really good party. His voice loops and swoons around, adding a thoroughly inebriated energy to the song. It’s a spaced out cobra snake dance of sultry, off kilter weirdness, like trying to do some sort of seductive dance while navigating through the shifting elements of a funhouse. This, I mean in an entirely good way. Somehow, it provides a wonderful intro to the night’s music, trailing off into Jack Straw which steps up and delivers something of a more standard early 80’s show opener. The band pulls everything together and hammers out the goods.

The set continues along with fine music eventually reaching Bird Song. This isn’t the titanic version we’d hear six days later, but it is no less enjoyable. Painted with huge, broad stroke swells in energy, the songs is a wonderful ride. It provides a lovely infusion of psychedelic energy into the first set, gently reaching toward the gold ring deep inside.

The set ends with a Hell In A Bucket > Day Job. The Bucket is tight and energetic, brimming with that certain something that was growing to drive this band into the massive popularity to come over the next many years. Day Job is Day Job. What can you say? From here we head into the second set where most of the action is anyway.

China Cat pours out in that carnival kaleidoscope of sound that we’ve heard before on 05/13/83. Interestingly it isn’t a quality that pervades every China>Rider from 1983, but does seem to appear here and there. I can’t put my finger on just why one version seems to express this, while another just four or five days in either direction doesn’t, but the 10/11 version has it. With a dance of cartoonish colors splattering into each other as the landscape can’t help but dance to the music, Garcia’s solos coil and spin like a laughing serpent in the sun, climbing like hungry ivy over tree trunks. The music is bound like a puzzle of interlocking gears, each rippling waves of heat from their core out into the meshing teeth of each neighbor.

After this wonderful China>Rider, the band must pause due to a blown speaker in Jerry’s rig. And it is highly possible that it is this unexpected pause in the flow of set two which sets the stage for the unique musical path that follows. Over the minute or two where Garcia’s speaker is replaced, Bobby settles directly into playing I Need A Miracle, a tune that otherwise would not necessarily logically show up after a second set opening China>Rider. What follows proves one of the laws related to the Grateful Dead:

Thou shall not judge a set by its set list.

I can promise you that on my journey into the 80’s I naturally shied away from this set list in particular. In fact, looking at it, I can recall the mere appearance on paper seemed to support my then desperately wrong assumptions about the 80’s. It looked like a total snoozer. A Miracle>Bertha>China Doll before Drums? Are you kidding me? Yeah.. you weren’t kidding me.

Not being a big Miracle fan myself, I must admit that this version is infectious. Perhaps it’s the entire combination of the recording quality, odd set placement, and the energy from the crowd that no doubt casts an intoxicating vapor over the band , but this tune is a pleasure to behold. As it eases out, we hear the glimmers of a really nice jam appearing – something like the way unique improv could always follow on the heels of He’s Gone. As this interesting space is beginning to open up, Jerry decides to fly into Bertha (whoa!), and we turn somersaulting into a lightning hot version of the tune, completely out of its element in the second set. Those friends out West won’t believe it when they hear about this second set after the show. What a hysterical understatement that makes at this point in the set.

Jerry Garcia - September 11, 1983And now we get that jam. Descending upon us like a slow rolling blanket of Northern Lights, a gorgeous improv ensues. I remember clear as day the first time I listened to this tape. I was sitting in my backyard, late at night under a star filled sky. It was early on in my journey toward appreciating the 80’s, and I was already fairly impressed with how much I had enjoyed the second set up to this moment. As this jam played out, I began to lose myself into the grass below me. I can close my eyes and return to that night – see my garage across the lawn, feel the slightly cool night air around me, even recall that soft giggle as I delighted in stumbling across this transcendent magical moment lurking in 1983. This might have been one of the first times I stood completely dumbfounded by Dead music not made before 1980. As the music expanded, sounding something similar to a liquid Playin’ In The Band jam made even more hypnotic in the way it appeared out of absolutely nowhere, the only thing that ground me back to this universe was the burning desire in my heart to start collecting more and more and more of this stuff. For me, the 80’s would be an acquired taste, like anchovies. From this moment on, I would happily consider adding anchovies to every pizza I ordered. My brain now had a fully formed lobe set aside for music from the early 80’s. And of course, I still hadn’t heard the part of the show that drew me to getting it in trade – that drew just about anyone to want to get this show in trade.

The jam settles into an undisturbed lake at sunset, and China Doll shimmers into view like the first stars waking in the early night’s sky. This draws the entire crowd deep into the Grateful Dead’s most comforting embrace. The feeling of sitting cozily around the embers of a campfire with Jerry spinning a ghost story is pervasive. This is another of those wonderfully intimate moments with the Grateful Dead, probably lost on a person who hasn’t “gotten it” as we like to say. Perhaps it is thereby made more soulfully resonate for those of us who consider ourselves more in tune to the frequency. Perhaps, since none of its energy is spent on ears not listening for it, ours are treated to an even larger dose. Deliciously, the song plays out at the end for a long while, gently rocking to and fro, nestled beneath a canopy of blurring starlight, settling us gently at the feet of Drums and Space.

Space doesn’t take too many chances. But it’s building up to something rather grand, so I won’t knock it. As the band rings out Saint Stephen’s opening notes, you can hear a slow swell of shocked cheers from the crowd. They mount like a tidal wave which crashes as the entire band hit’s the song’s head and the singing begins. You can’t miss the charge of energy which ignites the entire affair. The song does not go off without its share of slight glitches, and even a near train wreck toward the end where everything very nearly pitches right off the deck. They save things, but it’s not perfect. This is something of a microcosm of everything Grateful Dead. Historically famous for their inability to rise to big occasions, they prove that they are a band with that most precious ability to mine the golden magic of musical inspiration, and demonstrate that it is something nearly impossible to summon up on demand. Their stumbling through this great Saint Stephen return just confirms that these guys are who they are. Personally, I’m happy to have them as is, willing to forgive them most everything.

Again, there are a lot of different recording options for this date. I’ll point you to the Silberman master below, but encourage you to do some exploring on your own just for fun. This show was persevered by a couple other famous Dead tapers, Jim Wise and Rob Eaton. So, there’s a good deal of good tapes to enjoy from this date.

10/11/83 AUD etree source info
10/11/83 AUD Download


  1. I was sitting behind the stage at this show. Jerry was facing us, fiddling with his amp or controls when he hit the "magic note," then turned around and the band began in earnest. Part of my delight was watching the folks down in front of the stage erupt in rapturous glee when they realized that St. Stephen was "in the Garden."

    Having been at Nassau four years earlier for the last Stephen (and last show with Dark Star and St. Stephen the Grateful Dead ever performed) made this one more special.

    Your review is spot-on in that there is a lot of other good music from this night that is often over-looked. The sweet surprise came the next night with the first performance of Revolution, a delightful 2-night stand at MSG.

  2. Hey! Hey! My first tape gets "the treatment!" Spot on, review. The whole pre-drums sequence is a marvel and I blew out a tweeter at a CATS session during that Miracle a couple years back.

    Also, I love the Space for sentimental reasons and think it's just exactly perfect. Good schtuff!

  3. Nice show. These early-80s Birdsongs chained me to the bus forever. I was out in LA by this time, and I distinctly remember stoping some random heads on the Venice boardwalk to pass along the earth-shattering news that "I heard they played St. Stephen and Phil sang!"
    one little quibble: Steve or Jeff Silberman?

  4. thank you, noah! This is one I'd passed on time and again for later ones in the month (Worcester, Hartford, so on), being underwhelmed by the setlist and never being won over by the break-out factor. Looks like it's high time to settle in with this one and make up for some lost time!

  5. The discerning listener will note that as the band starts "Fortune comes acalling..." the crowd noise perceptably rises. This is the true seminal moment of this show as its the moment that Phil Lesh steps up to the mike to join the fun after quite the absence. Way cool moment, and one that still amps me up when I hear it all these years later.

  6. For anyone ever caught in the "auds v SBDs" argument, where the SBD snob simply can't find a reason why an aud could be superior, I'd simply direct them to this show. I was there that night, and when they dropped into St. Stephen, the roof of the Garden actually lifted off the building. The electricity, the energy was that palpable. And that can ONLY be captured on an audience tape.

  7. I was also at this show and had been doing the whole tour (deep into my Dead-touring days at this point). Many of us knew Stephen was likely coming soon. They had sound-checked it at Richmond and many of us listened excitedly with ears pressed to the locked doors of that intimate stadium just days before. They even toyed with it in Space that night. But word quickly spread and the Boys themselves even put out the word to West Coast friends and family that they might want to make the trip out to NY for something special. So it was in the air from the word "go." As amazing as it was (and it was AMAZING!), I like the Hartford Stephen that followed even more. At that point, everyone who had missed the breakout were eager and praying that they, too, would get to experience a St. Stephen. And so they did. And when that first note hit, the roof flew off once again. There was one more Stephen to follow (for the West Coast) and then no more. Though L.A. almost got one in the 90's apparently, though the show didn't sell out so the Boys decided otherwise. Or so the rumor goes. I was there, too, just in case. Thanks for the memory!

    1. I was ther in Hartford and happened to be standing next to a cop when those first notes were played and the place went beserk and the poor cop was panic stricken!

  8. 10/11/83 was at the show with my best friend Adam . Outside the garden he states "the dead are going to play saint stephen tonight. " I reply they dont play that anymore . We make our way to the front row . Out of space comes saint stephen from the front row right beofore our eyes . True story and one of many very special dead moments !

  9. this was my first dead show what a blast to have it again

  10. The second set of this show was one of the first Dead recordings I ever had, and it will always hold a special place in my heart for many of the reasons you mention here, especially the pre-drums segment. There is definitely some odd mystical quality to the odd tune placement in that section of the show. I hadn't heard this show in many years and listened to it recently and it still has a unique sound to me.

  11. I wasn't there and enough has been said about St. Stephen. Nothinig I can add there. However, my favorite parts of the show other than the aforementioned is definitely Birdsong and then the Jam>China Doll before drums. I can't count how many times I play the sequence over and over. China Doll has always been a favorite, particulularly the lyrics..."All I leave behind me is only what I found"...


Blog Widget by LinkWithin